The Moonshot
S02:E02

The Moonshot

Episode description

The Moonshot

How can Solarpunk address the problems of a massive project, like travel to the moon? Will the genre crumble under the need for macro-level power and industry? Come explore the latest story prompt and dream of a future together.

Transcript: https://wiki.tomasino.org/writing/Solarpunk-Prompts---The-Moonshot

Links mentioned:

Music from:

‘Last And First Light’ and ‘Artemis’ by Scott Buckley - www.scottbuckley.com.au (CC-BY 4.0)

Download transcript (.srt)
0:07

Hello World, I'm Tomasino.

0:10

This is SolarPunk Prompts,

0:13

a series to inspire storytellers,

0:16

where we discuss solar punk,

0:17

a movement that imagines a world where technology is used

0:21

for the good of the planet.

0:23

In this series,

0:24

we spend each episode exploring a single solar punk story

0:28

prompt, adding some commentary, some inspirations,

0:32

and some considerations.

0:34

Most importantly,

0:36

we consider how that story might help us to better envision

0:39

a sustainable civilization.

0:42

If this is your first time here,

0:44

I'd recommend checking out our introduction episode first,

0:47

or the season's introduction,

0:48

where we talk about what solar punk is,

0:51

why you should and why this series came into being.

0:56

Today's prompt is the Moonshot.

1:00

A group of scientists, environmentalists, and politicians,

1:04

such as lobbyists to the UN,

1:07

are analyzing the footprints of the solar panels and

1:10

windmills around the world, trying to answer the question,

1:14

is sending a rocket to the moon and back to get a ton of

1:17

moon soil?

1:18

The best thing we can do in the middle of a climate crisis?

1:22

Is moon helium fusion the best way forward?

1:27

Today,

1:29

only about 17% of our world's energy production supply

1:33

comes from low carbon energy,

1:36

and only about 12% from renewables.

1:39

We hope that our future situation will continue to change,

1:43

and our communities will find new and varied ways of moving

1:51

toward distributed power generation, local power,

1:55

and smaller sustainability.

1:57

We also need to acknowledge that our capacity for the

2:00

future is growing.

2:00

for large -scale energy generation is taking a step

2:03

backward.

2:05

It is the idea and ideal of solar punk to envision the

2:09

world where local environmental balance and sustainable

2:12

practices mean our need for this large power network is

2:17

diminished.

2:18

And what we see in homegrown communities living this model

2:22

today, those expectations are fairly realistic.

2:26

But what happens when we need to do more?

2:29

What happens when our communities need to act big or act

2:33

together on a macro scale?

2:36

In this prompt,

2:37

we ponder the need to do something monumental,

2:40

traveling to the moon.

2:42

Even today,

2:43

this is a massive undertaking that simply not feasible for

2:46

many nations around the globe.

2:48

We have highly technical societies with massive power grids

2:52

and industries capable of so much.

2:56

Yet the resources required for such a thing still pose

2:59

problems.

2:59

It may be a lack of physical resources, the fuel creation,

3:03

or the material sciences needed for a heat shield.

3:07

Or the challenges may be political,

3:09

with dominant forces asking why their efforts should go to

3:13

such a wild idea,

3:15

even in wealthy societies with true abundance there can be

3:19

a disconnect between the mission and the benefit in the

3:22

eyes of the people.

3:23

And to be fair,

3:25

the connections aren't always immediately obvious.

3:29

Take for example some recent research from the European

3:32

Space Agency, frying potatoes in space.

3:37

Scientists looked at the complex physics and chemistry

3:41

involved in frying,

3:43

testing the process at increased gravitational forces in a

3:47

centrifuge, and at low gravity in a parabolic flight test.

3:51

They learned that the optimal gravity for french fries is

3:55

3G.

3:57

They also learned that even in low gravity the movement of

4:00

bubbles still supports a workable frying method.

4:04

But why?

4:06

Why the research?

4:07

Why?

4:07

The expense of flight tests, over and over.

4:11

The immediate output is confirmation that astronauts who

4:14

hope to travel to Mars won't be stuck with rehydrated food

4:18

alone, they'll have some other options like boiling.

4:22

But more importantly,

4:23

these chemical and physical processes open the door to our

4:27

understanding of more complex subjects,

4:30

like producing hydrogen from solar energy in microgravity.

4:36

The silly french fry experiment might help us to create the

4:39

fuel needed for missions deeper into our solar system.

4:43

And it's not always clear why.

4:46

And that's an important theme to consider in your stories.

4:49

The human will to do a thing is the first and greatest

4:53

commodity needed.

4:54

One story you might look at for inspiration is Antirdena

4:58

Hudson's our shared storm.

5:01

The setting here is mostly centered around political

5:03

saloons and conferences,

5:05

but that doesn't mean the stakes are low.

5:07

There is plenty of drama as the stories play out across

5:11

five overlapping scenarios of a natural disaster,

5:15

striking Buenos Aires during a climate conference.

5:18

How do these scenarios play out scientifically,

5:21

but also politically,

5:23

with faction stemming from different regions?

5:26

Politics probably represents the most difficult aspect of a

5:30

scenario requiring this macroactivity.

5:33

If that's not your strong area,

5:36

or if you want to focus on something a bit smaller,

5:38

we could aim this moonshot project a bit lower.

5:41

Instead of the moon,

5:43

what about something that requires a few communities,

5:45

but not several nations to accomplish?

5:48

One notion might be a don't have meltdowns and burn out

5:57

much of the radioactive waste found in older uranium

6:01

reactors.

6:02

It's a stepping stone toward cleaner energy, doable today,

6:06

and could help generations to come.

6:09

From a philosophical view,

6:10

it seemed aimed in the right direction,

6:13

though there are valid criticisms to explore if you go down

6:16

that path.

6:17

Thorium -based reactors are also an option,

6:20

offering increased safety, less waste,

6:23

less radioactivity in the waste.

6:25

In either case,

6:26

the effort required to build such a thing is still more

6:29

than a small community can hope to achieve.

6:33

Thousands of skilled workers would need to team together,

6:36

and the raw materials for the facility and the fuel are

6:39

just not common.

6:41

How does such a thing come to be in your imagined future?

6:46

What are the many barriers?

6:48

What are the struggles?

6:49

A moonshot project is essentially a challenge to

6:53

SolarPunk's happy -go -lucky fetishization of windmills and

6:57

solar panels.

6:58

The aesthetic is confronted with a cold,

7:01

hard reality that there are things for which it may not be

7:04

well equipped.

7:06

What happens when we face these challenges head -on?

7:09

Who will want to buckle to the pressure and seek the easy

7:13

way out?

7:14

What sort of engineering insights and hard science might

7:18

you pull into the story to make the struggle

7:20

understandable?

7:22

If our goal is to create a vision for a possible future,

7:26

one where we have found some equilibrium with our

7:29

environment,

7:29

then we can use this sort of vehicle to demonstrate ongoing

7:33

challenges.

7:35

There is a common stumbling block for riders approaching

7:39

SolarPunk for the first time.

7:41

The utopian vision of these communities,

7:44

the struggle to fix everything is in the past,

7:47

and now it's all gardens and windmills.

7:49

And that suggests that conflict is already resolved.

7:53

For a rider who might be attracted the topic of climate

7:56

fiction,

7:56

writing something without that conflict sounds frankly

8:00

boring.

8:01

A prompt like this one may be a boon to such a writer.

8:05

Here we see communities who have come a long way and still

8:10

face new and ongoing challenges.

8:13

What if the distributed microgrids,

8:16

localized manufacturing and so on, are helping,

8:19

but are not enough?

8:21

What if we need to do a mega -project?

8:24

What if it's proven that it's not just a scam,

8:27

but every scientist can support its value?

8:30

Do we want to surrender the locality of our communities to

8:34

recreate hierarchy and create something truly big,

8:38

something that may be controlled by just a few people?

8:41

Can we allow that culturally?

8:44

If not, can we suffer the cost of inaction?

8:47

How can you raise the stakes even further?

8:52

These are big questions that go Beyond the technical,

8:56

though they may be grounded in it,

8:58

they go beyond the political,

9:00

though that may be where the conflict is expressed.

9:04

They're ethical questions,

9:06

they're essential questions of identity,

9:09

and that's anything but boring.

9:11

Finally, I encourage you to play with the norms.

9:15

In a world where Solar Punk has reached its first stage and

9:19

is struggling with its next step,

9:21

what has changed in the everyday mores that might help it

9:25

or might make it more difficult?

9:28

These everyday sensibilities will humanize and ground the

9:32

bigger action, making it more accessible to the reader.

9:36

These small things also tend to represent the values of the

9:39

people more effectively than the big thing.

9:42

How will your community safeguard their values as they face

9:46

these decisions?

9:48

Do they formalize protections by creating organizations?

9:52

Do they internalize new ideas of taboo?

9:56

A good resource on these ideas would be the Tetralogy Terra

10:01

Ignota by Ada Palmer.

10:04

In this series,

10:05

we see a playful treatment of the philosophy of cultural

10:09

morals, which manages to frame the future for us,

10:12

injects a position to our past.

10:15

We cannot help but see our own world through the eyes of

10:18

someone from the 18th century and thus better understand

10:22

the foreignness of the future.

10:24

And that may be an important element for us to consider as

10:28

readers.

10:30

The pathway to this better future is not just external,

10:34

it's not just the infrastructure or the politics.

10:37

It's also a part of our values and our cultural norms.

10:41

How will those change for us to get where we're going?

10:46

And how will those change once we get there?

10:50

Until next time,

10:51

I'm Tomasino and I hope you'll join me for the next series.

10:55

episode of Solar Pup Rhymes.

10:58

Music in this episode was from the tracks Last and First

11:18

Music by Scott Buckley.

11:18

Music by Scott Buckley.